An employer may not use a standard form to require an employee, in the event of the early return of a company car, to pay the employee’s share of the cost of optional equipment in a lump sum by the end of the lease term. This applies in particular when the employer reclaims the vehicle in connection with termination of employment.
The Duisburg Labor Court ruled that a corresponding provision in a company car policy was invalid (judgment of April 29, 2026 – 4 Ca 9/26). The appeal filed against this decision with the Düsseldorf Regional Labor Court was withdrawn after the Regional Labor Court expressly indicated during the hearing that it shared the legal opinion of the court of first instance (Düsseldorf Regional Labor Court, hearing transcript dated October 6, 2026 – 11 SLa 384/26). The decision is final.
Invalid Clause Regarding Special Equipment
In the case at hand, the employee had made monthly contributions toward special equipment he had requested for his company car, which he was also permitted to use for personal purposes. The company car policy provided that, in the event of early return of the vehicle, all remaining lease payments due through the end of the lease agreement would be deducted from the employee’s wages. This clause is invalid. It unreasonably disadvantages employees (Section 307 of the German Civil Code (BGB)) because it imposes the full economic consequences of early return on them: The vehicle must be returned, the right to use it ceases—yet at the same time, the employee is required to continue paying the future costs of the special equipment immediately. The operational and financial risk is generally borne by the employer. If the employer decides to terminate the employment relationship and therefore demands the return of the company car, it cannot shift the associated costs to the employee through general terms and conditions. The desire for a vehicle with higher-end features does not justify a different assessment.
The settlement clause does not cover the proper settlement still owed
The settlement clause agreed upon in a settlement agreement regarding protection against wrongful termination was also of particular significance. According to this clause, fulfillment of the settlement agreement was intended to settle all financial claims arising from the employment relationship and its termination. The Labor Court clarified: Such a clause does not preclude the right to payment of unjustifiably withheld compensation if the settlement agreement simultaneously provides that the employment relationship must be properly settled and wound up until its conclusion. In this specific context, this obligation encompasses not only the preparation of a final pay statement but also the payment of compensation in accordance with the contract and the law. An unlawful withholding cannot therefore be settled by a general settlement clause. Otherwise, a settlement obligation expressly assumed in the settlement agreement would be immediately nullified by the settlement clause.
Practical Implications
Employers should review their company car policies to determine whether they include flat-rate payment or offset obligations for future lease payments in the event of early return. Such clauses are legally challengeable—even if the costs are based on special equipment requested by the employee.In labor court settlements, the interplay between settlement provisions and compensation clauses is also crucial. If a proper settlement and resolution of the employment relationship are agreed upon, the compensation claims covered by this agreement generally remain enforceable as long as the employer has not fully fulfilled its obligations.
Alexander Goldberg; Attorney at Law
Certified Attorney Specializing in Intellectual Property Law – Certified Attorney Specializing in Information Technology Law (IT Law)
